Tuesday, August 23, 2011

TILA Rescission Claim

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit recently held that the testimony of a borrower alone is sufficient to overcome TILA's presumption of delivery of TILA disclosures.

A copy of the opinion is available at:

http://www.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/094055p.pdf

The borrower brought a TILA rescission claim, specifically alleging that she did not receive the notices of her right to cancel at the closing on her home, and further, that to the extent she did receive the notices in the mail after the closing, they were not clear and conspicuous as required by TILA because they listed the wrong final rescission date and because they were received only after the loan funds had been disbursed.

Thus, according to the borrower, TILA's three-year extension of the right to rescind under the mortgages was triggered. The jury entered a verdict in favor of the lender on this TILA rescission claim.

On appeal, the borrower challenged various aspects of the jury instructions, including the District Court's instruction that because her signature was on the notice of right to cancel, "something more than just [her] testimony . . . is needed to rebut the presumption that she received" the notice.

Examining the jury instruction at issue, the Court noted that, unless Congress or the Rules of Evidence provide otherwise, "a presumption in a civil case imposes the burden of production on the party against whom it is directed, but does not shift the burden of persuasion." Further, "the introduction of evidence to rebut a presumption destroys that presumption, leaving only that evidence and its inferences to be judged against the competing evidence and its inferences to determine the ultimate question at issue."

The Court then examined the language within TILA, specifically the provision stating that when a borrower signs a "written acknowledgment of receipt" of the disclosures required by TILA, his or her signature "does no more than create a rebuttable presumption of delivery thereof." The Court concluded that this language in TILA indicated that Congress did not intend that something more than the testimony of a borrower was required to overcome TILA's rebuttable presumption of receipt. Thus, the District Court's jury instruction to the contrary was in error.

Thursday, August 18, 2011

Foreclosure Cases

http://richmangreerblog.com/2011/08/

This W. Palm Attorney does an awesome job briefing all the foreclosure cases in Florida each week.   Check him out.

Cal App Rules in Favor Of MERS in Wrongful Foreclosure Action, Rejects Allegations as to Improper Assignment of DOT

The California Court of Appeal, First District, recently held that: (1) in an action for wrongful foreclosure, the trial court had properly taken judicial notice of MERS's status as the lender's nominee; (2) the borrower's amended complaint did not state a cause of action arising from MERS's alleged improper assignment of the deed of trust; and (3) the borrower failed to state a claim for breach of an alleged foreclosure forbearance agreement, because the borrower did not attach to her complaint a copy of the document that purported to amend the agreement.


A copy of the opinion can be found at:

http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov/opinions/documents/A130478.PDF

This case arose from a mortgage loan under which Mortgage Electronic Registration System, Inc. ("MERS") was identified in the deed of trust as the nominee of the lender. The borrower defaulted on her loan and, at some point thereafter, MERS assigned "all beneficial interest" under the deed of trust, including the note, to HSBC Bank USA, N.A. ("HSBC"), as trustee. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. ("Wells Fargo"), as the servicer of the loan and, acting on behalf of HSBC, subsequently recorded a substitution of trustee naming another defendant as the trustee, and allegedly foreclosed on the property and sold it.

The borrower filed suit seeking damages and an order voiding the foreclosure suit and her debt. The focus on appeal was the fourth amended complaint against Defendants-Respondents, Wells Fargo and MERS. The borrower alleged that the foreclosure was supposedly unlawful because: (1) MERS supposedly lacked the authority to assign the deed of trust and note to HSBC; and (2) Wells Fargo had purportedly breached an agreement with the borrower not to foreclose.

The borrower alleged she had a forbearance agreement under which Wells Fargo would suspend foreclosure proceedings if the borrower made a certain number of specified monthly payments. The forbearance agreement also provided that failure to make the required payments permitted Wells Fargo to terminate the agreement and to proceed with foreclosure. Soon after entering the alleged agreement, however, the borrower received a letter (the "March letter") from Wells Fargo stating that the "monthly mortgage
payments were being reduced . . . for the next six months." In accordance with the March letter, the borrower submitted a reduced payment amount. Wells Fargo then allegedly refused to accept the payment as
satisfaction of the borrower's obligations and proceeded to foreclose.

The trial court ordered the borrower to attach a copy of the purported "Special Forbearance Agreement" to her fourth amended complaint. The trial court then sustained Wells Fargo's demurrer without leave to amend partly because the fourth amended complaint failed to show reliance on the forbearance agreement, as the borrower attached only the original forbearance agreement to her complaint, but not a copy of the March letter that purported to amend the agreement.

With respect to MERS, the borrower alleged among other things that MERS was not the "true" beneficiary under the deed of trust, never had ownership of the promissory note, and never held an assignable interest in the note or deed of trust. In its demurrer, MERS argued that the borrower's allegations were contradicted by copies of the recorded documents MERS submitted to the court, including the assignment of the deed of trust. The trial court took judicial notice of these documents and sustained the MERS demurrer without leave to amend. The trial court noted that the borrower's claims did not state a cause of action against MERS because the "only apparent grounds for suing MERS are the allegations that the deed of trust improperly named MERS as nominee and beneficiary, and that there was no physical delivery of the note to HSBC."

The Court of Appeal agreed with the trial court in all respects.

First, the appellate court rejected the borrower's argument that it was error to take judicial notice of the recorded real property documents attached to MERS's demurrer and noted that where the authenticity of the documents is not being challenged, it is permissible to take judicial notice of the legal effect of the documents. The Court of Appeal cited a number of court decisions that "establish that a court may take judicial notice of the fact of a document's recordation, the date the document was recorded and executed, the parties to the transaction reflected in a recorded document, and the document's legally operative language, assuming there is no genuine dispute regarding the documents' authenticity." The Court also noted that, contrary to the borrower's assertion, "MERS's status as beneficiary was not the type of fact that is generally an improper subject of judicial notice . . . since its status was not a matter of fact existing apart from the document itself." Instead, the Court noted, "MERS was the beneficiary under the deed of trust because, as a legally operative document, the deed of trust designated MERS as the beneficiary." The Court also observed that court decisions have generally found that the use of MERS as beneficiary does not invalidate otherwise proper foreclosure sales.

Also rejecting the borrower's argument that MERS had the burden of proving that a valid assignment had occurred, the Court noted that the nonjudicial foreclosure process is afforded a "presumption of regularity." Moreover, the Court stated that, contrary to the borrower's assertions, "the lack of a possessory interest in the note did not necessarily prevent MERS from having the authority to assign the note." The Court noted that as the lender's nominee, MERS had the authority to act as the lender's agent and that the complaint failed to show that MERS, as the nominee, lacked the authority to make the assignment of the note on behalf of the lender.

The Court also pointed out that in order to state a claim that the foreclosure sale was invalid because HSBC lacked the authority to foreclose, the borrower was required to allege not only that the MERS assignment was invalid, but also that HSBC did not receive an assignment of the debt in any manner whatsoever, which the borrower failed to do.

The Court observed that, unlike assignments of security interests, assignments of debt are commonly not recorded, and the original "lender could readily have assigned the promissory note to HSBC in an unrecorded document that was not disclosed to the [borrower]." The borrower had also failed to demonstrate how she had been prejudiced by the MERS assignment, especially in light of the general expectation that the promissory note would be assigned and that her obligations under the note to pay remained unchanged. The court also rejected the borrower's contention that the deed of trust was ambiguous.

As to the claim against Wells Fargo for the alleged violation of the forbearance agreement, like the trial court, the Court of Appeal noted that the borrower had failed to attach a copy of the March letter to her complaint even though the trial court granted her leave to amend on condition that she attach a copy of the forbearance agreement to her complaint. Noting that ordinarily the borrower would not be required to attach a copy of the March letter to the complaint, the Court pointed out that in light of the trial court's previous ruling on the earlier demurrer, the borrower was required to attach a copy of the original forbearance agreement as well as the March letter, which purported to amend the forbearance agreement on which she based her claim.

Finally, the Court also concluded that the borrower's complaint did not state a claim for promissory estoppel, because the borrower had given proper consideration in exchange for Wells Fargo's promise in the forbearance agreement not to foreclose.





Friday, August 12, 2011

New Eviction Method

http://consumerist.com/2011/08/landlord-suspected-of-releasing-thousands-of-scorpions-to-get-tenants-out.html

Interesting Site

http://consumerist.com/2011/08/

iPad or Other Tablet?

I want an IPAD- I covet the iPad and would love for Apple to send  me one like they have some legal blogger-- her that Apple?

But  there is even more reason to chose the iapd with all the IP suits and drama
http://www.law.com/jsp/lawtechnologynews/PubArticleLTN.jsp?id=1202510777839

Braids being cut off

What is going on in NY?   We have children getting their braids cut off on the way to school
http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive-free/pdf?res=F10610FC345F10738DDDAE0A94D9405B8185F0D3

We have children getting their braids cut off in Kindergarten by classmates
http://www.essence.com/2010/02/24/bullies-cut-5-year-old-girls-hair/
They're young, but shouldn't they know better? If not addressed, the psychological effects of long-term bullying are bad enough without tacking on that now this five-year-old girl has to walk around with a patch of hair missing from the back of her head. 

Schools and Judges taking no action
http://www.cltmag.com/us-judge-finds-no-constitutional-damages-claim-in-bullying-case.html

Teacher chops off child's braid
http://www.essence.com/2009/12/15/crazytown-usa-braids-not-safe-in-milwauk/

 People need to teach their children to keep their hands off of other people  PERIOD.

When my son was in Pre-school- a religous one mind you, another child cut my son't face- he was 3 and 1/2 at the time. The school did nothing about it.   My son still has a scar to this day although a faint one.   I really wish I would have sued the school and the parents of the little psychopath !!  The  school system needs to protect these kids system needs to protect these kids.  It's just hair it will grow back is not acceptable.


Are we in a Recession or is it still to come?


I personally thought we were in a Recession, but the experts say it's still coming. See the attached story.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/print/2011-08-11/recession-threatening-u-s-after-household-spending-s-consecutive-declines.html

Bankruptcy filings up in 2010 from 2009- No Suprise.

The Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005 requires the director of the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts to submit an annual report to Congress on certain bankruptcy statistics.

The report, which includes multiple charts and an interactive map, shows that more 1.5 million bankruptcy petitions were filed by individuals with predominately nonbusiness debt in 2010 – an increase of 9 percent over 2009.

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

London Riots?

The following was a quote about the riots in London off reuters.com:



“multicultural society, as the history shows, never works in times of lack of prosperity!

Real calamities always unite a culturally homogenous society-Japan an example; divides even more multicultural ones..

You are right! The changes to the unsustainable social systems are coming! “

I was wondering?

So what we start kicking people out of the country? Once we deport the foreigners,  who do we start on next? And what about those with multi ethnic backgrounds, which country do we send them to? How far back do we go since only the Indians were here in the first place and we decimated their civilization. Do I get to stay because I have 1/2  British Ancestors? Are there really any homogenous societies left?

OCC Consent orders

http://alfn.site-ym.com/resource/resmgr/Docs/Bank_of_America.pdf


http://alfn.site-ym.com/resource/resmgr/Docs/Citibank.pdf

http://alfn.site-ym.com/resource/resmgr/Docs/HSBC.pdf

http://alfn.site-ym.com/resource/resmgr/Docs/J.P._Morgan_Chase.pdf

http://alfn.site-ym.com/resource/resmgr/Docs/LPS;_DocX.pdf

http://alfn.site-ym.com/resource/resmgr/Docs/MERSCORP.pdf

http://alfn.site-ym.com/resource/resmgr/Docs/MetLife.pdf

http://alfn.site-ym.com/resource/resmgr/Docs/PNC.pdf

http://alfn.site-ym.com/resource/resmgr/Docs/U.S._Bank.pdf

Thursday, August 4, 2011

Murder Goes Uncharged 2 years Later

Robert Wone arrived at their house alive, and Joseph Price, Victor Zaborsky and Dylan Ward were in the house, and he ends up dead with three stab wounds to his chest,” Wone's widow said. “My gut definitely tells me that they were in some way involved in killing Robert…. They’re hiding behind the Fifth Amendment, and that is, I guess, the way they want to live their lives.” The three men were charged in late 2008 and early 2009 with obstruction of justice and conspiracy to obstruct, and then acquitted in a bench trial. No one has been charged with murder in the case. Authorities say the criminal investigation is ongoing. In finding Joseph Price, Esq., Victor Zaborsky and Dylan Ward not guilty on all counts, Leibovitz said that, while prosecutors had provided “powerful” evidence suggesting that one of the three housemates/ domestic partners  either stabbed Washington attorney Robert Wone or knows who did, the government failed to prove “beyond a reasonable doubt” that they intended to disrupt the investigation into Wone’s death.

http://legaltimes.typepad.com/blt/files/ward_affidavit

Note in Ward's room
A New Yorker magazine on the floor was opened to an article titled "Late Works, Writers Confronting the End." along with SM torture devices and a set of knoves missing the knife size of Wone's wounds.

Personal Data Usage

In question is nonpublic financial information of consumers and customers as such terms are defined in the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act of 1999. According to the U.S. Code (USC), the term “nonpublic personal information” means personally identifiable financial information that is “provided by a consumer to a financial institution, resulting from any transaction with the consumer or any service performed for the consumer or otherwise obtained by the financial institution.”


The operative phrase is “financial” information. This, of course, would include account numbers, account balances and other nonpublic financial information regarding the consumer, including the fact that the consumer is in default. It does not, however, include property and other public records or information widely available through published telephone books, Internet social sites, etc. Nor does it apply to identifying information - such as a name, address or phone number - so long as the identifying information is not linked to the nonpublic information. the information can be shared with and by persons and entities seeking to assist in enforcing the transaction. Nothing in the codes calls for consent, written or otherwise, by the consumer. This is clearly not an oversight by Congress, as the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) makes specific provisions for some requirements to be in writing, but not for others. The issue of financial institutions sharing consumer nonpublic information is generally covered under Section 313.1 of the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR)

Fannie Short Sale Partner

The Five Star Institute, a mortgage industry group based in Dallas, Texas, announced a partnership with Fannie Mae to educate real estate agents on Fannie Mae’s Short Sale Assistance Desk (SSAD). Fannie Mae’s SSAD helps expedite the process by allowing real estate agents to reach out to Fannie Mae directly for short sale approval of first-lien, Fannie Mae-backed loans. Agents can access the appropriate forms through multiple listing services (MLS).


The Five Star Institute is the parent company of DS News magazine and DSNews.com

Thursday, July 28, 2011

Credit Counseling Certificates for $25.00 and Debtor Counseling for $15.00

It's simple to receive your Debtors Education certificate:

1. Go to http://www.accesscounselinginc.org - Click on Get your Certificate Today


2. Read and agree to Disclaimer

3. Follow on-screen instructions to register be sure to enter my access code at the bottom of the registration page - this is CT46FTD for my office only-if you are not my client do not use

4. Complete the course and your certificate will be processed and delivered promptly.