Monday, July 19, 2010

Hamilton v. Lanning (U.S. 6/7/10)

When a bankruptcy court calculates a debtor’s projected disposable income, the court may account for changes in the debtor’s income or expenses that are known or virtually certain at the time of confirmation.

In re: Johnson Sixth Circuit July 2, 2010

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit recently held that the “enabling loan exception” of Section 547(c)(3) of the Bankruptcy Code did not protect an auto finance company’s security interest from avoidance as a preferential transfer during a Chapter 7 bankruptcy proceeding, because under Kentucky law final perfection of a vehicle lien does not occur until physical notation is made on the title, which did not occur within 20 days after the debtor received possession of the collateral.


Plaintiff-Debtor executed an installment sales contract and security agreement with defendant Branch Banking & Trust Company (“BB&T”) to finance an automobile purchase on February 8, 2005, and took possession of the automobile that same day. The title documentation and fees were received by the Letcher County, Kentucky clerk’s office on February 22. However, the county clerk did not stamp the documents as received and upload BB&T’s lien for recordation until March 7. Less than ninety days later, Debtor filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, and the bankruptcy trustee filed a complaint to avoid the lien of BB&T as a preferential transfer.

The Bankruptcy Court held that BB&T’s security interest was perfected on February 22, and that the “enabling loan exception” protected BB&T’s interest. The Bankruptcy Appellate Panel disagreed, holding that that BB&T’s interest was not protected by the exception because perfection occurred on March 7. The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed.

Under Section 547(b) and (c) of the Code a “trustee may avoid certain transfers of interest in property that occur on or within 90 days preceding the filing date of the bankruptcy petition.” However, the “enabling loan exception” under Section 547(c)(3) protects a purchase money security interest if the security interest is perfected within 20 days after the debtor receives possession of the collateral.

Perfection of a security interest is determined by state law, and therefore the question before the Court was whether perfection of a security interest on a motor vehicle under Kentucky state law “require[s] physical notation on the actual certificate of title as ultimately issued by the county clerk, or is perfection accomplished as and when the required paperwork and fee are submitted to the county clerk?” Upon certification to the Kentucky Supreme Court, that Court concluded that “final perfection of a vehicle lien does not occur until physical notation is made on the title.” Johnson v. Branch Banking & Trust Co., -S.W.3d-, 2010 WL 2470849, at *1 (Ky. June 17, 2010).

Accordingly, the Sixth Circuit held that because perfection did not occur within 20 days after Debtor received possession of the truck, the enabling loan exception of Section 547(c)(3) did not protect BB&T’s interest from avoidance as a preferential transfer.

Fannie, Freddie Transition to Over-The-Counter Trading

As of July 8th, 2010, shares of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are trading exclusively on the over-the-counter (OTC) market.


This announcement comes shortly after the Federal Housing Finance Agency directed the companies to voluntarily delist their common and preferred stock from the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) and any other national securities exchange.

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were ordered to delist because their common stock price had hovered near the NYSE minimum average closing price requirement of $1 for more than 30 trading days for most months since the two government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs) were placed into conservatorships in September 2008.

Fannie Mae said its common stock, which previously traded under the symbol “FNM,” will commence trading on the OTC Bulletin Board under the symbol “FNMA.” And shares of Freddie Mac’s common stock, which traded on the NYSE under the symbol “FRE,” will now trade under the symbol “FMCC.”

Shares of each of the GSEs’ preferred stocks will also take on new trading symbols on the OTC market.

In a statement, Freddie Mac noted that the transition to the OTC market will not affect the company’s obligation to file periodic and certain other reports with the Securities and Exchange Commission under applicable federal securities laws.

30-Year Fixed-Rate Mortgages Hit New Record Low

The weekly mortgage rate reports released Thursday by Freddie Mac and Bankrate were mixed. But one thing was certain: the average rate for 30-year fixed-rate mortgages hit a new record low.


According to Freddie Mac’s Primary Mortgage Market Survey, 30-year fixed-rate mortgages averaged 4.57 percent with an average 0.7 point for the week ending July 8, 2010, inching down from last week’s average of 4.58 percent. Freddie Mac said this rate marked yet another all-time low in its 39-year survey.

Bankrate also reported a decline in 30-year fixed-rate mortgages. According to its weekly mortgage survey, rates averaged 4.74 percent with an average 0.39 point this week, falling from last week when 30-year fixed-rate mortgages averaged 4.75 percent.

Pending Legislation

H.R. 5043, the "Private Student Loan Bankruptcy Fairness Act of 2010."


H.R. 4953, the "Mortgage Servicing Conflict Elimination Act of 2010."

H.R. 4950, the "Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Administration Improvement Act of 2010."

H.R. 4677, the “Protecting Employees and Retirees in Business Bankruptcies Act of 2010.”

H.R. 4506, the “Bankruptcy Judgeship Act of 2010.”

H.R. 4173, the "The Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act."

S. 1927, the "Credit Card Rate Freeze Act of 2009."

H.R. 3890, the "Accountability and Transparency in Rating Agencies Act."

H.R. 3818, the "Private Fund Investment Advisers Registration Act of 2009."

H.R. 3817, the "Investor Protection Act of 2009."

H.R. 3639, the "Expedited CARD Reform for Consumers Act of 2009."

Credit-card debt drops 10.5% in May

by Becky Yerak

Posted Thursday at 2:49 p.m.

Paying down credit-card debt appears to be on the upswing.

Consumers cut their outstanding revolving debt -– overwhelmingly credit cards -– by an annualized, seasonally adjusted rate of 10.5 percent in May, the Federal Reserve reported Thursday. That’s on the heels of an 11.8 percent drop in April. Revolving credit is a line of credit allowing consumers to pay all or part of an outstanding balance, and, as the balance is paid, it becomes available to spend again as credit.

But it might be premature to say that consumers have been scared straight.

The monthly consumer credit numbers tell only part of the story because it’s not yet known how much debt banks or merchants will charge-off, or remove from their books because they’ve deemed it uncollectable. The Fed’s charge-off numbers are released quarterly, and the first quarter’s 10.1 percent rate tied for the highest since the beginning of 1985, the latest period for which figures are readily available.

“Unfortunately we won’t know until the charge-off data comes out for the second quarter whether the reduction was actually due to consumers paying down their debt or the banks writing bad debt off the books,” Odysseas Papadimitriou, a former Capital One executive who is now founder and chief executive of credit-card research Web site Cardhub.com, said.

In the first quarter, for example, about 40 percent of the decline in credit-card debt was due to charge-offs, Cardhub.com said.

And though consumers did pay down $36 billion in credit-card debt in the first quarter, that’s still 23 percent less than they repaid a year earlier, it said.

Another reason for the drop in outstanding revolving debt: lenders have been tighter with credit with existing cardholders, giving them less rope to get in over their heads, a new study shows.

New credit-card limits from banks are just 40 percent of what they were in 2006, according to Equifax. And even year-over-year reductions in average credit limits -– to $4,000 from $4,600 -– means 13 percent less credit available for cards with the same credit score, the credit-data business said.

Finally, consumer bankruptcy filings nationwide totaled 770,117 in the first half of 2010, up 14 percent from a year earlier, according to the American Bankruptcy Institute. The bankruptcy process cancels many debts.

“All these factors suggest there is less credit in the system,” said Equifax, which has credit files on nearly 200 million U.S. consumers.

Indeed, there’s evidence consumers with active cards are paying them down, one study shows.

Though home-equity lines that consumers once used like personal ATMs are shrinking, credit-card debt per borrower is falling nationally, statewide and in the Chicago area, according to TransUnion.

Credit card debt per borrower in the Chicago area averaged $5,119 in the first quarter, down 10 percent from a year earlier and 6 percent from the fourth quarter, the credit-reporting firm found.

“We anticipate the decreasing trend in credit card debt that started in the second quarter last year to continue well past the second quarter this year,” TransUnion director Ezra Becker said.

Meanwhile, personal savings rates as a percentage of disposable personal income were 3.5 percent in the first quarter of 2010, down slightly from 3.7 percent in the year-ago quarter, according to the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis. But it’s up significantly from the 1.2 percent rate in the first quarter of 2008.

http://chicagobreakingbusiness.com/2010/07/revolving-consumer-debt-down-0-5-in-may.html

 
 
Equifax, which has credit files on nearly 200 million U.S. consumers.

Circuit Court of Appeals Cases

2nd Circuit Court of Appeals, June 22, 2010
In re Delta Airlines, Inc., --- F.3d --- (2nd Cir. 2010)(sustaining of objections to claims under tax indemnification agreements reversed where: 1) court's construction of "pay" in agreement in error; and 2) the bankruptcy court effectively nullified the agreements by stripping them of their ability to protect the Owner Participant in the event of debtor's default)

5th Circuit Court of Appeals, June 21, 2010
In re Wilborn, --- F.3d --- 5th Cir. 2010)(proposed class in this case did not satisfy the requirements of FRCP 23 and FRBP 7023)

7th Circuit Court of Appeals, June 23, 2010
In re McKinney, --- F.3d --- (7th Cir. 2010)(appeal dismissed for lack of jurisdiction as, although the issue that the tax debt owner cares about may have been resolved, its basic dispute with the bankruptcy estate has not been resolved and therefore the judgment of the bankruptcy court is not final)

10th Circuit Court of Appeals, June 23, 2010
In re Trout, --- F.3d --- (10th Cir. 2010)(trustee, having successfully avoided a preferential vehicle lien under section 547, the trustee was not entitled to a money judgment equal to the value of the avoided liens under section 550(a), where the bankruptcy estate had been sufficiently returned to its pre-transfer status by avoiding the preferential lien at issue and stepping into the lien priority of the avoided creditor under section 551)

U.S. Supreme Court, June 17, 2010

Schwab v. Reilly, --- US --- (2010)(debtor gave “the value of [her] claimed exemption[s]” on Schedule C dollar amounts within the range the Code allows for what it defines as the “property claimed as exempt,” the trustee was not required to object to the exemptions in order to preserve the estate’s right to retain any value in the equipment beyond the value of the exempt interest)

1st Circuit Court of Appeals, June 15, 2010
In re Nosek, --- F.3d --- (1st Cir. 2010)(In a creditor's appeal from a $250,000 sanction issued sua sponte by the bankruptcy court, the sanction is reduced to $5,000 where: 1)creditor's claim that it was the holder of the mortgage at issue was not a deliberate falsehood or intended in any way to mislead the court or debtor or achieve anything for creditor; and 2) the bankruptcy court did not identify any actual prejudice from the inaccurate claim of holder status)(Note: David Souter sat on the panel in this appeal)

2nd Circuit Court of Appeals, June 15, 2010
SEC v. Byers, --- F.3d --- (2nd Cir 2010)(In nonparties' appeal from the district court's order holding that its jurisdiction in rem and its equitable powers provided it with sufficient authority to issue an injunction barring non-parties from filing involuntary bankruptcy petitions against any of the defendants, the order is affirmed where, while it should be sparsely exercised, district courts possess the authority and discretion to enter anti-litigation orders, including those that bar the filing of involuntary bankruptcy petitions absent the district court's permission)

9th Circuit Court of Appeals, June 09, 2010
In re Southern Cal. Sunbelt Developers, --- F.3d --- (9th Cir. 2010)(In actions seeking damages for filing of involuntary bankruptcy petitions against two alleged debtors, judgment for damages is affirmed in part where: 1) 11 U.S.C. section 303(i) permits an award of attorney's fees for a section 303 action as a whole, including fees incurred to litigate claims for fees and damages under section 303(i)(1) and (2); 2) section 303(i) permits an award of punitive damages under section 303(i)(2)(B) in the absence of an award of actual damages under section 303(i)(2)(A); and 3) award against two individual appellants jointly and severally liable for the costs and attorney's fees the debtors incurred in obtaining dismissal of the involuntary petitions is proper. However, the judgment is reversed in part where the bankruptcy court erred by holding the individual appellants liable for the debtors' costs and fees incurred on the section 303(i) motions themselves)




Thanks to Findlaw.com

Schwab v. Reilly, --- U.S. ---, 2010 WL ------- (2010)

Schwab v. Reilly, --- U.S. ---, 2010 WL ------- (2010)

Issue: Is a chapter 7 trustee required to object to the valuation of property claimed exempt by a debtor on schedule C within the 30 day time limit proscribed under FRBP 4003?
Holding: No.
Justice Clarence Thomas for a 6-3 court,

Ginsburg dissented with Roberts and Breyer joining

Debtor valued property for less then it's value.  Trustee failed to object.  Trustee asked court to allow him to sell property and give the Debtor her exempted value. The debtor objected arguing that, by the time of the hearing on the sale motion, it was too late to sell the property since the trustee had not objected to the exemption. “She argued that by equating on Schedule C the total value of the exemptions she claimed in the equipment with the equipment’s estimated market value, she had put [the trustee] and her creditors on notice that she intended to exempt the equipment’s full value, even if that amount turned out to be more than the dollar amount she declared, and more than the Code allowed.” She indicated that she would prefer her case be dismissed rather than have the equipment sold. The bankruptcy court agreed with the debtor and denied the motion to sell the property. The district court and the court of appeals both affirmed. The court of appeals ruled that by using the same amount to value the property and claim the exemption, she “indicated” an intent to claim all of the property as exempt. “Such an identical listing put [the trustee] on notice that [the debtor] intended to exempt the property fully.” This triggered the trustee’s duty to object within the statutory period.
The Supreme Court reversed.

The debtor is entitled under section 522(b) to exempt property listed in section 522(d). Section 522(l) states, “[u]nless a party in interest objects, the property claimed as exempt on [Schedule C] is exempt.” But under 522(l) the debtor may only claim exemptions under section 522(b) and therefore the trustee has a duty to object only if the exemptions claimed are improper under 522(b). Since the debtor had the right to claim $10,718 exempt, there was no requirement that the trustee object. Most exemptions “define the ‘property’ a debtor may ‘clai[m] as exempt’ as the debtor’s ‘interest’—up to a specified dollar amount—in the assets described in the category, not as the assets themselves.”


“[T]he Code’s definition of the ‘property claimed as exempt’ in this case is clear. As noted above, §§522(d)(5) and (6) define the ‘property claimed as exempt’ as an ‘interest’ in [the debtor’s] business equipment, not as the equipment per se. Sections 522(d)(5) and (6) further and plainly state that claims to exempt such interests are statutorily permissible, and thus unobjectionable, if the value of the claimed interest is below a particular dollar amount.”

The decision also discusses the relationship between this case and the earlier Supreme Court case of Taylor. In Taylor, the debtor listed the value of the exemption as “unknown.” This made the claimed exemption objectionable on its face because the statutory exemption was limited to a certain amount. When the trustee did not object, his right to object was lost. There is also a discussion about the practical effect of the ruling, that is, the delay and uncertainty to the debtor caused by the failure of the trustee to timely object. The decision states that if it is important to the debtor to claim the asset itself exempt, the debtor may list the “exempt value as ‘full fair market value (FMV)’ or ‘100% of FMV.’"

In her dissent, Justice Ginsburg focuses on the language of section 522(l) and FRBP 4003(b) which says that unless a party in interest objects, the property claimed by the debtor as exempt is exempt. She says that the debtor “made her position plain,” she listed each item of property and a specific value for each and claimed each exempt. “Because an asset’s market value is key to determining the character of the interest the debtor is asserting in that asset, Rule 4003(b) is properly read to require objections to valuation within 30 days, just as the Rule requires timely objections to the debtor’s description of the property, the asserted legal basis for the exemption, and the claimed value of the exemption.” She argues that the trustee is required, as part of his duties, to determine the value of every asset in a case anyway and if he needs more time, he can ask for more time or simply continue the meeting of creditors so that the 30 time limit will be delayed.

Minority Borrowers Disproportionately Damaged by Foreclosure Crisis

The report – Foreclosures by Race and Ethnicity: The Demographics of a Crisis – found that while the majority of families who have lost their homes are non-Hispanic and white, African-American and Latino families have been disproportionately affected relative to their share of mortgage originations. Among recent borrowers, CRL estimates that nearly 8 percent of both African-American and Latinos have lost their homes to foreclosure, compared to 4.5 percent of whites.


These racial and ethnic patterns are likely to continue in the future, CRL said. According to the report, non-Hispanic whites represent the majority of at-risk borrowers, but African-American and Latino borrowers are more likely to be at imminent risk of foreclosure – which refers to the number of borrowers who are two or more payments behind on their mortgage combined with those who are already in the foreclosure process. While 14.8 percent of non-Hispanic white borrowers are considered at “imminent risk,” 21.6 percent and 21.4 percent of African-American and Latino borrowers fall under this category.

When the number of homes that are in imminent danger of foreclosure is combined with homes already lost, CRL estimates that 17 percent of Latino homeowners, 11 percent of African-American homeowners, and 7 percent of white homeowners have already lost or are at imminent risk of losing their home.

Home Equity Loan Delinquencies Fall for First Time in Two Years: ABA

According to ABA’s first quarter Consumer Credit Delinquency Bulletin, home equity delinquencies fell for the first time in two years to 4.12 percent of all accounts, down from 4.32 percent the previous quarter. During the same period, home equity lines of credit delinquencies fell to 1.81 percent from 2.04 percent, and property improvement loan delinquencies fell to 1.4 from 1.63 percent.

GSEs’ Mortgage Guarantee Fees on the Downswing

The average guarantee fee charged by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac on single-family mortgages fell to 22 basis points in 2009, dipping down from 25 basis points in 2008, according to a report released by the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA).


FHFA said these fees cover projected credit losses from borrower defaults over the life of the loans, administrative costs, and a return on capital.

The decline in guarantee fees reflects reductions in both the average ongoing fee and the average upfront fee. According to the report, the average ongoing fee fell to 13 basis points from 14 basis points, and the average upfront fee dropped down to 9 basis points from 11 basis points.

FHFA said the drop in total guarantee fees in 2009 resulted from a significant improvement in the credit profile of the single-family mortgages the government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs) acquired relative to 2008. On a year-over-year basis, there were improvements across the product, credit score, and loan-to-value ratio spectrums.

These improvements came as 15-year fixed-rate mortgages grew as a share of total acquisitions, borrower credit scores improved, and fewer loans with down payments were acquired. In addition, the share of mortgages with risk layers—multiple features that increase credit risk—fell significantly from one year to the next.

According to FHFA, the positive development in the credit profile of enterprise acquisitions in 2009 also reduced the average expected costs of bearing the credit risk of those loans. The agency said the net effect of lower costs and lower guarantee fees charged was an improvement in the estimated fee gaps for the three major product categories, including 30-year fixed-rate, 15-year fixed-rate, and adjustable-rate mortgages.

For mortgages acquired in 2009, each GSE set the guarantee fees at levels sufficient to cover expected costs and to provide a modest return on capital. The sole exception to this policy was for loans originated under the Home Affordable Refinance Program (HARP), which offers Fannie and Freddie a benefit in the form of reduced credit exposure. Although the fees charged for HARP loans were not expected to achieve the targeted rate of return, FHFA said the new loans should perform better than the mortgages they refinanced.

Hurley v Deutsche Bank. ( 6th Cir App) 2010

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit recently held that a delay of over two years before attempting to compel arbitration resulted in waiver of the right to arbitrate.


Plaintiffs filed an action in May of 2007 in federal court against certain mortgage lending defendants for alleged violations of the Servicemembers’ Civil Relief Act. The matter was litigated in federal court for approximately 26 months before the defendants sought to compel arbitration under the terms of the mortgage documents executed by the Plaintiffs. The district court denied the Defendants’ motion and the Defendants appealed.

Agreeing with the lower court the Sixth Circuit found that, the Defendants in this matter waived their agreement to arbitrate by both “(1) taking actions that are completely inconsistent with any reliance on an arbitration agreement; and (2) delaying its assertion to such an extent that the opposing party incurs actual prejudice.”

Defendants acted inconsistently with their arbitration agreement by filing “multiple dispositive and non-dispositive motions,” including a motion to change venue under which, “Defendants proactively selected the forum in which the wished to defend against Plaintiffs’ claims.” In addition to Defendants’ conduct, the Sixth Circuit indicated that the length of time alone likely would have been dispositive. In addition, the Sixth Circuit found that the Defendants’ delay in asserting their right to arbitrate prejudiced the Plaintiffs by causing them to incur costs of over two years active litigation in two federal courts.

Bank of the Prairie v. Picht (In re Picht),2010 WL 1768238 (10th Cir. BAP May 4, 2010) (Rasure

 A lien on an under-secured, modifiable mortgage in a “Chapter 20” case will not be released if the debtor does not receive a discharge in the Chapter 13 case.

Bankruptcy Filings On The Rise

It's tough out there -- no jobs, home values plummeting -- and Americans are reacting by heading to bankruptcy court.

Bankruptcy filings surged 14% during the first half of 2010, according to the American Bankruptcy Institute. Filings totaled 770,117 through June, compared to 675,351 during the same period last year.

In 2005, bankruptcy filings totaled more than 2 million. It is expected that there will be more than 1.6 million new bankruptcy filings by the end of 2010. The institute also said that bankruptcies totaled 126,270 in June, a jump of 8.5% from the same month in 2009, when they totaled 116,365.

There are 15 million Americans who are looking for work. And, the overall unemployment rate, which includes both those who are actively looking for work and those who are not, registered at 16.5 percent. As the number of unemployed workers swell, many Americans are anxious for the immediate passage of the unemployment extension 2010 bill.

The American Bankruptcy Institute, on the other hand, revealed that consumer bankruptcy filings for January to June increased by 14 percent over the same period last year. 770,117 consumer bankruptcy filings were registered during the first six months of 2010, which marks the highest number of filings since the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act was enacted five years ago to curb the increase in filings.


The relationship between unemployment rate and the rate of bankruptcy filings is best demonstrated in Nevada. Nevada has the highest unemployment rate in the country (adjusting for households located in the state) and it alshttp://all247news.com/wp-admin/post-new.php#o registered more than double the national consumer bankruptcy filing rate. Nevada registered 15,000 filings per million households compared to the 6,800 filings per million households average at the national level.

Both bankruptcy and jobs statistics do not augur well to unemployed Americans most of whom are pinning their hopes on Congress to pass legislation on the $33.9 billion unemployment extension 2010 bill.

Law Librarians

Firms have many labels for this type of work -- business development, business intelligence, competitive intelligence, business background searches, due diligence, conflicts, and client intake information, among others. But regardless of their names, all of these functions can be supported by the information professionals in the library or research department. Whether the firm needs creditworthiness information regarding a potential client's business partner or seeks to monitor the landscape and identify the major players and projects in a particular industry, law librarians are a powerful asset. In some cases, the need will be "one time" for a particular business background report on a company; in others, the typical workflow involves ongoing, complex project management, and continuous updating and tracking of critical information.


While the J.D./M.L.S. combination is well-known, particularly in academic settings, law librarians working in private firms often hold an M.B.A. or other business-oriented degree. As a result, many are proficient at analyzing the competitive environments in which a given company or industry operates -- sometimes referred to as the Five Forces, or SWOT (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats) analyses.

http://www.law.com/jsp/lawtechnologynews/PubArticleLTN.jsp?id=1202463252361